Outer Sunset

Devil's Teeth Baking Company

Bakery
Devil's Teeth Baking Company

Why go

The biscuit is the engine

The breakfast sandwich is the whole argument at Devil's Teeth Baking Company, and the buttermilk biscuit underneath it is what makes the argument specific. Owner Hilary Passman started from a plain Outer Sunset problem: she wanted a complete breakfast sandwich to take away, and nobody nearby was making the version she had in mind. Months went into it, testing biscuit recipes and cooking eggs every way she could think of until the texture held against the crumb rather than sliding off it.

The route in was not a restaurant concept. Before opening in 2011 she had practised law on the East Coast, moved to San Francisco in 1996, sold wedding cakes and baked pastries wholesale for cafes. One early baker later brought in a family biscuit recipe she judged better than her grandmother's, and the sandwich moved again.

Built for the weekend rush

This is a neighborhood bakery built for volume and pickup rather than lingering. The company works the outer edges of San Francisco and runs several counters, on Noriega Street, on Balboa Street and at Embarcadero Center, which makes the experience closer to a counter bakery than a quiet cafe with a pastry case.

Weekends are the tell. Lines run down the street and the bakery can put out six hundred breakfast sandwiches in a day, a number that explains the rhythm better than any description of the room: staff building sandwiches in sequence, a queue waiting on one item, and a reputation resting on doing that single format at neighborhood scale, over and over, without it slipping.

Order the sandwich first, then look at the bars

Start with the breakfast sandwich, the item that opened the first Noriega Street shop and still the clearest expression of the place. The biscuit is not a side here; it is the bread the eggs were designed around, which is why the sandwich holds together in a way most do not.

Then look at the pastry case, which reads like a staff notebook. Brownies and lemon bars go back to Passman's home and wholesale years. The ube blondie bar came from a Filipino baker whose grandmother made ube cake. The coffee cake came from another baker's mother. Those are working recipes brought in by the people baking them rather than a fixed corporate list, and they are the reason to add something sweet to a sandwich order.

Tags

CozyClassicHidden GemEnergeticBrunchStandalone

Frequently asked questions

What should I order at Devil's Teeth Baking Company?

The breakfast sandwich, which the bakery was founded to make and still sells by the hundred on weekends. The buttermilk biscuit is the point of it, developed over months of recipe testing before the shop opened in 2011. Add a bar from the case afterwards: the ube blondie or a lemon bar are the sweeter counterweight.

Where do the pastry recipes come from?

Several come from the bakers themselves. The ube blondie bar was developed by a Filipino baker whose grandmother made ube cake, and the coffee cake came from another baker's mother. Brownies and lemon bars go back to the owner's years baking at home and wholesaling to cafes before Devil's Teeth opened.

Compare nearby places

Nearby bakeries and places with a similar feel
VenueTypeArea
Day MoonBakeryOuter Sunset
Polly Ann Ice CreamCaféOuter Sunset
Black Bird Bookstore & CaféCaféOuter Sunset
AndytownCaféOuter Sunset
Andytown Coffee RoastersCaféOuter Sunset